Why Nostalgia Clouds Our Judgment

Our memories can play tricks on us. Good leadership needs to balance emotion and clarity.

“We are all sensitive to the splendors of beginnings, to the rare quality of those moments when the present is freed from the past without as yet letting anything shine through of the future that sets it into motion.” — Marc Augé, 2004

Nostalgia is something of a false prophet.

It feeds us powerful visions: memories of a glorious experience of the past—something that makes us long to relive it, like a first visit to a favorite location or a first viewing of a classic film.

Yet we can never reclaim it.

Therein lies the deceptive power of nostalgia. It’s able to create a deep and meaningful feeling within us, but it’s not the same as delivering an experience.

Especially at the holidays, when our playful memories serve up visions of sugarplums, snow angels, and laughter around the fireplace.

But it isn’t quite powerful enough to inoculate us from the cold reality of holidays past, present, and yet to come: recycled fruitcake, scraping ice off of windshields, and the rising voices of family squabbles.

Why do we go on believing in the romance of the past?


The Magic Elixir of Nostalgia

Nostalgia is defined as “a wistful yearning for a return to some past period or irrecoverable condition.”

It’s a feeling that wraps around us like a favorite sweater or a particularly enjoyable food from our childhood. The result is a sense of warmth and comfort (hence the term “comfort food”).

Incidentally, comfort foods don’t contain any magic elixir or healing properties; it’s the very memory of them that acts as a gentle salve for our troubled minds. They bring us a sense of belonging.

And really, isn’t that just what anyone wants? To belong.

Whether it’s a friend, family member, or an employee on your team, we all want to feel as if we’ve found the proper place in the world, that we’re useful to others, and that we're appreciated.

Perhaps this is why some employees revert to what they know and reject outright any new ways of considering things when presented with innovative alternatives. Cleaving to the known indicates a sense of belonging, a sense of community.

“But there can be no grave for Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson...Shall they not always live in Baker Street? Are they not there this moment, as one writes? Outside, the hansoms rattle through the rain, and Moriarty plans his latest devilry. Within, the sea-coal flames upon the hearth and Holmes and Watson take their well-won case...So they still live for all that love them well; in a romantic chamber of the heart, in a nostalgic country of the mind, where it is always 1895.” — Vincent Starrett, 1933

When we wax nostalgic, we call to mind “the good old days,” or that “romantic chamber of the heart” that Vincent Starrett referred to above.

It’s similar to our discussion of origin stories in a recent newsletter. We long for those days when things were simpler, when challengers were fewer, and it was easier to discern between right and wrong.

Consider Facebook’s initial stated intent of making the world a more connected place, or Google’s pledge to not be evil. Without foreknowledge of the complex world and competing human desires into which technology thrust itself, these platitudes are nostalgic.

Yet we can never reclaim them. We can’t unring the bell.

You might even wonder if things ever were that unfettered.

The unspoken promise of the Make America Great Again message is to return America to a better, simpler time; to some, that means the 1950s, when suburban America was growing, kids were home and at the dinner table at 5:00 pm (which of course the housewife prepared), and life was like an episode of Leave It To Beaver.

(Aside: is it just a coincidence that the family in Leave it to Beaver was named Cleaver? As we try to cleave to that era…)

That’s nostalgia.


The reality of the time, though? Women didn’t have as many choices in terms of careers, were underpaid (and still are), and were victims of sexual harassment that could never be admitted in polite company.

The Civil Rights Act hadn’t yet been passed, and Black Americans had to fight to eat at the same lunch counters as whites, struggled to be able to vote as easily as everyone else (and still do), and sue their way to be able to attend a local school.

“And the time and place and all the great events are near and dear to us not because our memories call them forth in pure nostalgia, but because they are a part of us today.” — Edgar W. Smith, 1946

One form of nostalgia practiced in plenty of companies is the classic mantra “we’ve always done it that way.” Defensive long-term employees (those with an institutional memory—which itself isn't a negative) flex their WADITW muscle not by virtue of seniority, but as an autonomous response to avoid change.

As stated above, perhaps it’s desperation for a sense of belonging.


Progress and nostalgia are diametric opposites.

Tweet this quote

Progress pushes us forward, sometimes into cold and unfamiliar territory, where we make decisions we’re not comfortable with. We may eventually find our footing, but those first steps can be scary.

Conversely, nostalgia keeps us rooted in the past. It tethers us to the familiarity and comfort that actions, repeated by rote, bring us over time. The danger is we might be mindlessly moored to ideas and practices, without considering alternatives.

There’s nothing wrong with evoking nostalgia; many of the retro themes or vintage products we see today (pick your CPG, QSR, or other company of choice—from retro bottles of Mountain Dew to website quizzes on which household items you remember from the '70s or '80s) draw on our collective memories of experiences past.


Even Ebenezer Scrooge was visited by nostalgia in the form of the Ghost of Christmas Past, which brought him back to his childhood. For a while, he enjoyed it: happy scenes like his beloved sister Fan, a Christmas party hosted by his former boss, Mr. Fezziwig, who treated him like a son, and his fiancée Belle.

But when the ghost showed him a scene of Belle ending their relationship because she couldn’t be with a man who loved money more than her, the reality was too much for Scrooge:

“Spirit.” said Scrooge in a broken voice, “remove me from this place.”

“I told you these were shadows of the things that have been,” said the Ghost. “That they are what they are, do not blame me.”

“Remove me.” Scrooge exclaimed, “I cannot bear it.”

“tell me what you forget and I will tell you who you are.”

Tweet this quote

Marc Augé wrote, “tell me what you forget and I will tell you who you are.” When we gloss over our past or even introduce a romantic, nostalgic element to it, we do a disservice to ourselves and to others.

When we share stories of our past, it’s perfectly acceptable to yearn for them again.

At the same time, we might yearn for a better future by learning from our past.

Thanks, and I’ll see you on the internet.

Please consider sharing this, encouraging someone else to sign up for the newsletter, or subscribing if you don’t already.

Join Now


About the top image

In William Shakespeare's The Tempest, Miranda is the daughter of Prospero. She was banished to an island at the age of three, along with her father, where they lived for over a decade with only their only company their slave, Caliban. Miranda is blissfully unaware of the evils of the larger world and is openly compassionate.